Jan 17, 2015
by Bob Sloan
For years VLTP, Center for Media and Democracy, PRWatch, Common Cause and other organizations have reported upon alumni of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) taking positions of authority in state and federal agencies. In these articles/reports we have shown how easily and surreptitiously ALEC’s agenda can be pursued at all levels of government. The below Ohio/Kasich/Snitchler case is just one of many involving ALEC alumni in key positions advancing ALEC’s ultra-conservative agenda while enriching corporate members.
In Ohio ALEC alum Governor Kasich appointed state Representative and ALEC member Todd Snitchler to head that state’s Public Utility Commission in 2011.
As the new Chairman, Snitchler immediately increased rate hikes for ALEC corporate members, Duke Energy and American Electric Power (both ALEC members). Immediately following the increases, Snitchler and PUCO had to reverse themselves and throw out the rate increases that cost commercial and residential customers huge power increases.
Today 87 ALEC alumni are U.S. Congressional members. Historically ALEC’s congressional alumni have successfully pursued many of ALEC’s initiatives at the federal level as we again reported in 2012. Many ALEC alum moved on to positions within the U.S. Department of Justice (or were recruited from there) or staff for Cabinet Secretaries.
This week E & E Publishing, Inc. reported that an organization had been formed – the Association of Air Pollution Control Agencies (AAPCA) – . The stated goal of the AAPCA appears to be to thwart federal air regulations pursued by the 34 year old non-profit, National Association of Clean Air Agencies, or NACA. The article announced the AAPCA had chosen a new Executive Director. He is Clint Woods…again an ALEC alum that moved on to the U.S. House and became a member of the House Subcommittee on Energy and Environment. He also was a staff member of the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology through the first quarter of 2014.
in 2011 Woods, serving as ALEC’s Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Director, wrote an article titled “Combating the EPA Regulatory Train Wreck” in ALEC’s April “Inside ALEC” edition under the heading: “EPA’s Reglatory Train Wreck, Strategies For State Legislators”: .
In the article Woods writes:
In response to the growing morass of regulations
proposed by the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), the American
Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC)
released EPA’s Regulatory Train Wreck: Strategies
for State Legislators. The report serves
as a toolkit for states to use in understanding
and combating these regulations,
which both burdens finite state resources
and impedes on the states’ role in our system
In may of last year, Greenpeace reported Woods as being an activist for ALEC in an article titled: “CASE STUDY: Koch Front Groups Attack RGGI – the Northeast Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative“ writing:
Koch-funded front groups – led by Americans for Prosperity (AFP) — joined right wing mouthpieces like Glenn Beck and others who labeled RGGI a “cap and tax” initiative. Conservative activist Clint Woods of the Koch-funded American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) stated that RGGI and other regional cap-and-trade regimes had become the “new battlefield” since federal climate legislation was defeated…”
“…This strategy was confirmed in September, 2010 by conservative activist Clint Woods of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), who said RGGI and other regional cap-and-trade regimes have become the “new battlefield” since federal climate legislation was derailed. ALEC, which has created template legislation for state lawmakers to use as a way to back out of regional climate accords, received $125,000 from the Koch brothers’ Claude R. Lambe Charitable Foundation in 2009 and has received donations totaling $533,000 from the Koch foundations since 1997. Koch Industries consultant and former executive Mike Morgan sits on ALEC’s Private Enterprise Board, and Wall Street Journal editorial board member Stephen Moore, who has attended the Koch brother’s political strategy meetings, is on ALEC’s Board of Scholars.
Already the AAPCA claims 17 state members: Ohio, Florida, Indiana, Louisiana, North Dakota, Texas — that have already left the NACAA – and 11 states that joined but retain NACAA memberships: Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, Nevada, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia and Wyoming. If you see that member states are those with Republican controlled state legislatures and/or Governors, we see that as well.
This demonstrates how ALEC (through the funding of Koch controlled foundations and ALEC’s corporate member funding) is able to advance each of key initiatives beneficial to their corporate members without the government or public becoming aware of ALEC’s involvement or real legislative controls. Recently several major corporate members of ALEC withdrew from the organization citing opposition to ALEC’s position regarding climate change and renewable energies.
VLTP would urge readers to do a small amount of research into ALEC connections in your key state agencies. You may be surprised how simple it is to cross reference the name of heads of state agencies with the American Legislative Exchange Council to determine any relationship or ties. Right now energy resources and pollution are key issues being fought at all levels of government. You can rest assured ALEC is in the midst of each skirmish, issue and overall war over climate change, support of the views of big oil, gas and coal corporations.
ALEC has shown they are able to “stack the deck” when it comes to issues important to their corporate members. It is up to us to ferret out these ALEC “sleepers” and remove them from their positions of influence. The AAPCA is another “non-profit” formed and funded with money originating from conservative organizations and donors. It needs to be added to the list of known ALEC affiliates. We can’t close them down…but they are deserving of our close attention to their activities and the names of all members who climb on board as the months pass.